Many U.S. doctors don’t discuss the harms of lung cancer screening or the potential for overdiagnosis in conversations with current and former smokers about whether tests are necessary, two new studies suggest.

The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommends that doctors engage patients in shared decision making, with thorough discussions about the risk and benefits of screening, before patients get a form of high-powered X-ray known as low-dose computed tomography—CT scans—to look for any abnormalities on their lungs, researchers note in one of the studies in JAMA Internal Medicine.

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services require proof of shared decision-making before they will pay for the test, the authors add.

To gauge whether this actually happening, the study team analyzed recordings of 14 conversations between doctors and patients about starting lung cancer screening. Every one of the physicians recommended screening, and discussion of potential harms was almost entirely absent from these talks.

“Conversations were uniformly brief and one-sided,” said senior study author Dr. Daniel Reuland of the Lineberger Comprehensive Cancer Center at the University of North Carolina Chapel Hill.

While screening may reduce the chance of dying from lung cancer by catching tumors sooner, most people don’t benefit because hundreds of patients need to be tested over many years just to prevent one death, Reuland said by email. Most of the time, CT scans detect nodules, or abnormal tissue, that aren’t cancerous, he added.

“Unfortunately, figuring out which nodules are cancer is hard and can require invasive procedures which can lead to complications and out-of-pocket costs, even for the people without cancer,” Reuland said.

In addition to these “false positives,” another of the potential harms of screening that doctors are supposed to discuss with patients is overdiagnosis—when screening catches a cancer that is so slow-growing it might never have caused symptoms, or at least not before the person died of some other cause.

“However, (these tumors) still usually get treated with chest surgery or other treatments, because figuring out which tumors don’t need aggressive treatment is difficult,” Reuland added.

On average, doctors in the study devoted only one minute to discussing lung cancer screening, during conversations that lasted an average of 13 minutes, the study found.

“For a cancer screening with such unclear net benefit and clear harms, it is particularly important that patients understand this balance before signing up for such a test,” said Dr. Rita Redberg, chief editor of JAMA Internal Medicine and author of an accompanying editorial.

“This matters a lot to patients, as they would have no way of knowing that their chance of benefit from the low dose CT is small and their chance of harm is greater,” Redberg, said by email.

A separate study in the same journal examined the risk of overdiagnosis after lung cancer screening. Researchers randomly assigned 4,104 current or former smokers to receive annual screenings or no screenings for five years, then followed patients for an additional five years.

Researchers estimated that about 67 percent of the cancers detected by screening represented overdiagnosis. This group did start out with a higher risk for lung cancer than the group that didn’t receive screening, the authors note.

“Overdiagnosis is a critical outcome to consider when making decisions about participating in lung cancer screening or not,” said lead study author Dr. Bruno Heleno, who did the work at the University of Copenhagen in Denmark and is now at the Nova Medical School in Lisbon, Portugal.

“Unfortunately, research shows that it is difficult to be certain about the true extent of overdiagnosis when screening with low-dose CT-scans,” Heleno said by email.

The USPSTF currently recommends that people aged 55 to 80 with a history of smoking the equivalent of a pack a day for 30 years get screened yearly with a low-dose CT scan.

Ex-smokers might want to think differently about screening than current smokers, said Dr. Mark Ebell, a public health researcher at the University of Georgia and co-author of an editorial accompanying the overdiagnosis study.

“I primarily encourage patients from 55 to 70 who are current smokers, since they have the greatest benefit,” Ebell said by email. “Older patients in good health can also consider screening, although it’s uncommon to find a current smoker over 70 years that doesn’t have other serious medical problems that limit the benefit from screening for lung cancer.”

Lisa Rappaport

From Reuters

Categories: Health Health News

Video Popular

  • Celebrating Arbor Day With Books

    Celebrating Arbor Day With Books

    Trees were once considered sacred and awe-inspiring: Oaks were worshiped by the European Druids, redwoods were a part of American Indian ritual, and baobabs a part of African tribal life. Ancient Chin ...

  • Sharks Eat Their Greens, Too—First Omnivorous Species Confirmed

    Sharks Eat Their Greens, Too—First Omnivorous Species Confirmed

    Not all sharks feed only on meat—at least one shark species also feeds on seagrass. Scientists have confirmed that one of the most common sharks in the world is an omnivore. The bonnethead shark, a re ...

  • Microsoft Flags Dangers to EU of Plans to Limit Data Use

    Microsoft Flags Dangers to EU of Plans to Limit Data Use

    Microsoft said on Sept. 5, that EU lawmakers’ copyright reforms limiting the use of potentially valuable data to non-profit bodies could damage the European Union’s digital development. Co ...

  • How Setting a Schedule Can Make You Less Productive

    How Setting a Schedule Can Make You Less Productive

    It can seem like there’s never enough time—not enough for sleep and not enough for play, not enough for cooking. and not enough for exercise. There’s a relatively new term to describe this feeling: ti ...

  • RiNo, Denver: America’s Best Place for a Bar Crawl?

    RiNo, Denver: America’s Best Place for a Bar Crawl?

    “RiNo reminds me of Williamsburg in 2004—just pretentious enough to be good, not yet pretentious enough to be annoying.” Kevin Burke is joking, of course. As the general manager of American Bonded—one ...

  • Respecting Teachers and Cherishing Virtue

    Respecting Teachers and Cherishing Virtue

    Respecting teachers and cherishing virtues are part of the traditional ethics practiced by the Chinese people. Teachers, who impart morality, knowledge, and values, teach people the proper ways to int ...

  • Home Ownership in Canada Declines, Reversing Long Upward Trend

    Home Ownership in Canada Declines, Reversing Long Upward Trend

    Home ownership in Canada fell for the first time in over 45 years, according to a Point2Homes study released this week. It had reached a record high of 69 percent in 2011, but as of 2016, it fell to 6 ...

  • Aretha Franklin Dresses, Hats to Go up for Auction

    Aretha Franklin Dresses, Hats to Go up for Auction

    NEW YORK—More than 30 dresses and accessories worn on stage by Aretha Franklin are going up for auction. The Queen of Soul died at age 76 in Detroit on Aug. 16. Julien’s Auctions says the items ...

  • 87 Elephants Found Slaughtered in Botswana, Africa

    87 Elephants Found Slaughtered in Botswana, Africa

    An alarming number of elephant carcasses have been discovered in aerial surveys across Botswana in what has been described as a “poaching frenzy.” Botswana was once known as a sanctuary fo ...

  • Yes, Marijuana Can Be Addictive

    Yes, Marijuana Can Be Addictive

    The business world is salivating at the potential $22.6 billion recreational marijuana market in Canada, with more new pot users expected after legalization on Oct. 17. But public-health officials wan ...

  • Google Races to Parry the Rise of Facebook in India

    Google Races to Parry the Rise of Facebook in India

    Google retains only a slight lead over Facebook in the competition for digital ad dollars in the crucial India market, sources familiar with the figures say, even though the search giant has been in t ...

  • Canada in Brief, Sept. 6-12

    Canada in Brief, Sept. 6-12

    Trudeau says he won’t use ‘tricks’ to ram through pipeline construction Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is pouring cold water on Alberta’s suggestion that the federal government use legislation or a cou ...